Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
USB to M.2 Expansion Board & Case Mounting Ears
#1
Lightbulb 
I know these are on the general market already, but have you considered making one that would be compatible with the Robo-Tank HATs & cases?  (https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0CBJYWKJ1/)  The SD card is, IMHO, by far the weakest point in the system due to write exhaustion.  An SSD offers much better longevity and resilience.  Expanding the depth of the lower half of the v3 case would allow adding the card.  They connect via 3 pins on the reverse side of the Pi for power, and via a USB bridge for signal.

It would entail having to modify the case to add it on.  I see a few ways to do this:
  1. With the board I linked, or one you mfg'd similar, the bottom of the case could be extended sufficiently and that's it.  Done.  Or;
  2. A little more ambitious, but extend the overall interior depth of the case up to about 40mm (currently ~30mm).  This provides enough room for the M.2 expansion board.  It would also allow for mounting a 60mm fan on the interior of the case such as a Noctua NF-A6x25 5V PWM.  Or; 
  3. Most ambitiously, increase the interior depth to around, and this is a guesstimate, 50-55mm.  We can easily fit the SSD expansion board.  We ALSO have sufficient interior room to mount a 40mm (Noctua NF-A4x20 5V PWM) on the interior on the side next to the 12v-24v DC Power input blowing ACROSS the Pi and the M.2.  Combine that with a PWM script, such as https://github.com/mklements/PWMFanContr...rtional.py, and we have a PWM cooling fan that is nearly silent on a Pi with SSD longevity.  Finally, add 'ears' to the side of the bottom clamshell, and we can mount case under the tank without having to resort to double sided tape. :P
What are your thoughts, Rob?
Reply to top
#2
The ears are always a good option for easy mounting, problem would be over tightening the screws resulting in cracks.
[-] The following 1 user Likes fietsenrex's post:
  • Rob F
Reply to top
#3
Hi Blake, thanks for the suggestion, I agree the SD card is the weak link, definitely better to use a high endurance card but it can still only handle so much. Pi has some boards with eMMC built in, I've thought it would be nice to have this one be compatible along with regular Pi's if they ever get stock levels figured out.

https://www.pishop.ca/product/raspberry-...cm4001008/

I could see that board you linked work seeing how it mounts on the bottom but yeah makes for a much thicker case.

Currently the easiest thing to do is use an external USB SSD drive which the Pi can boot from. Here's an article explaining how to set it up. I haven't done it but know a few people have.

https://www.makeuseof.com/how-to-boot-ra...t-storage/

I have started work on a v4 controller, although it's many months away, and plan to have the cooling fan back inside the case and maybe I can find some SSD like the one you linked that can fit as well.
Reply to top
#4
Let me know if / how I can help.
Reply to top
#5
Will do, if you try a regular USB SSD let me know it goes.
Reply to top


Forum Jump:

Current time: 04-27-2024, 04:27 AM